Appendix 4
Case study: BfL12 tool assessment – Claypole, Lincolnshire
BfL12 – Question 1
Connections
Does the scheme integrate into its surroundings by reinforcing existing connections and creating new ones, while also respecting existing buildings and land uses around the development site?
Rating and comments
GREEN
Access would be gained through a priority junction onto Doddington Lane in the south-eastern corner of the site. This location is the logical point of access for the site and matches the existing agricultural access. A footpath is proposed on the eastern side of the access road providing pedestrian and cycle access into the site. The footpath proposed within the development links to a new footpath that runs along Doddington Lane and connects to the existing footpath network in the village, providing a good link between the development and the existing village. The new scheme has been designed to respect existing development. Locating the access road and drainage swale on the boundary shared with existing development (Western Boundary) provides a buffer between the development and existing properties helping to maintain the amenity of existing properties.
BfL12 – Question 2
Facilities and services
Does the development provide (or is it close to) community facilities, such as shops, schools, workplaces, parks, play areas, pubs or cafes?
Rating and comments
GREEN
The development is located within walking distances of key amenities in Claypole including, primary school, playing field, pub, shop and the church. The layout enables access to footpath on Doddington Lane which links to the wider village network.
BfL12 – Question 3
Public transport
Does the scheme have good access to public transport to help reduce car dependency?
Rating and comments
AMBER
Site located within just over 400 metres of a bus stop, which provides regular connections to Newark and Grantham.
BfL12 – Question 4
Meeting local housing requirements
Does the development have a mix of housing types and tenures that suit local requirements?
Rating and comments
GREEN
Scheme designed to meet the specific needs of the village idenitifed by a housing needs survey (HNS). It is a 100 percent affordable housing development. The HNS identified a need for Affordable Rent and Shared Ownership units which are both included in the proposals. The SO and AR properties are evenly distributed throughout the scheme.
BfL12 – Question 5
Character
Does the scheme create a place with a locally inspired or otherwise distinctive character?
Rating and comments
GREEN
The scheme has been designed to have its own identity, while respecting that of Claypole. Claypole itself has no distinctive style or character, with varied built form throughout the village. The modern housing proposed in the development will link will to the recent housing developments to the west of the site. Claypole as a settlement does not have its own distinct characteristics or identity. The development has been designed to respect recent housing development to the west of the site to which it shares the closest relationship.
BfL12 – Question 6
Working with the site and its context
Does the scheme take advantage of existing topography, landscape features (including water courses), wildlife habitats, existing buildings, site orientation and microclimates?
Rating and comments
GREEN
Site is well contained with no significant long views into it. Properties on the eastern boundary have been designed to include hipped roofs to lessen the visual impact when being viewed from the east. The site has prominent field hedgerows on the southern and eastern boundaries. The layout has been designed to maintain and protect these hedgerows.
BfL12 – Question 7
Creating well defined streets and spaces
Are buildings designed and positioned with landscaping to define and enhance streets and spaces and are buildings designed to turn street corners well?
Rating and comments
GREEN
A well-defined space is achieved in the scheme through the positioning of dwellings facing the access road. Well positioned private drives are located on the eastern side of the site feeding off the main access road. Again, properties are orientated to face onto the private drives creating enclosed spaces within the development. There are no obvious corners within the development proposed. However, split orientated semi-detached plots have been included to ensure plots at the junctions of the access road and private drive face both roads (5 and 6, 7 and 8).
BfL12 – Question 8
Easy to find your way around
Is the development designed to make it easy to find your way around?
Rating and comments
GREEN
The scheme is small in nature and pedestrian routes are clear for future residents. The balancing feature/main open space is located in the centre of the small site, creating a focal point for the scheme. Mixed hard surfacing is included throughout providing clear areas within the site.
BfL12 – Question 9
Streets for all
Are streets designed in a way that encourage low vehicle speeds and allow them to function as social spaces?
Rating and comments
GREEN
Streets are short with a regular junction arrangement. Surveillance on the road is achieved through front facing properties. All houses well linked to shared surface private drives that will provide a safe and appropriate place for children to play.
BfL12 – Question 10
Car parking
Is resident and visitor parking sufficient and well integrated so that it does not dominate the street?
Rating and comments
GREEN
Two parking spaces are provided per plot. All parking provided on curtilage.
BfL12 – Question 11
Public and private space
Will public and private spaces be clearly defined and designed to be attractive, well managed and safe?
Rating and comments
AMBER
In terms of landscaping, hard and soft landscaping is proposed for the development, including relevant boundary treatments to enclose private curtilage areas from the public realm and street scene. This will complement the retention of many of the established trees throughout the layout, together with the additional tree planting, to achieve a high-quality landscape feel throughout. Overall, landscaping will be well integrated into the development, be visually attractive and make a positive contribution to natural drainage. The development is centred around public open space, which includes a Local Equipped Area for Play (LEAP). The proposed development includes the creation of new pedestrian links to integrate the development within the wider public realm and encourage accessibility and use of the Public Open Space for all users.
BfL12 – Question 12
External storage and amenity
Is there adequate external storage space for bins and recycling, as well as vehicles and cycles?
Rating and comments
RED
Bins will be stored in the back gardens of properties. Access from the garden to the street on bin days readily available. Cycle storage provided in back gardens.